Crochet or Knit

Today, I want to discuss some of the differences between crochet and knitting, specifically ways to achieve different results. How often have you seen a design for a knit garment and wondered, “Why couldn’t I crochet the same design?” And indeed you probably could. You will sometimes see patterns published for both crochet and knitting and many crocheters lament the fact that this is not done more often. What we need to keep in mind is that there is an inherent difference between the resulting fabric from crochet to knit. In sewing, we refer to this as the hand of the fabric. This means the texture, weight, and way the fabric drapes. This should be the first consideration when you make a crocheted project.

Crochet fabric is usually denser than knit fabric because of the nature of the technique. It is thicker and stiffer than knitted fabric when the same fiber and needle size are used. So, not only will you need more yarn or thread, but you will need to think about whether this heavier result will be acceptable to you in the finished garment. If it is a winter coat, you may like the thicker fabric which will result in a warmer garment. On the other hand, if it is a light summer top with draped neckline, just changing the pattern to crochet using the same fiber, weight, and hook will not give the desired result.

But there is another side to this issue. Do we want to copy and adapt knit patterns because there are so many more sophisticated stylish designs available? I would say, only if you just adore that pattern and you have a reason why you think it would be better as a crocheted garment. One of my goals in starting this website is to point out the beauty and strengths inherent in crochet. It is versatile and has a beauty all it’s own. It is not the ugly sister of knitting, but a similar craft that can be used to create fabulous projects that work best as crochet.

So, what are the considerations we need to keep in mind when deciding whether to knit or crochet? Some people find that one is easier than the other, but among people who do, I find they usually say one is easier than the other only depending on which they learned first. For those that do both crafts on a regular basis, they tend consider which technique works best for the project they have in mind. I’ve already mentioned the heavier weight and stiffer hand of crochet, but there are some obvious advantages, too. Crochet works well for light lacy patterns. It offers just a bit more stability and you can see the pattern developing as you progress. With knitting, a heavily textured or lacy pattern is harder to visualize until several rows down because of being bunched up on the needles.

This brings up another advantage with crochet. You can lay it out flat to measure your progress at any point. You have only one live stitch, so it is easier to frog back should you decide you want to redo a portion. As for finishing,  there are hundreds of pretty crocheted edgings and these can be used on knitted projects, as well.

Another advantage I see with crochet is for three dimensional objects like amigurumi. Since you can see your progress as you go along, you can easily make adjustments to get the desired shape. Crochet’s dense fabric leaves smaller holes and in many cases you can stuff a toy without a fabric lining. And when working smaller items, the hooked crochet project has a distinct advantage over trying to work a small item on knitting needles.

Fiber is also a consideration. You can crochet or knit with just about any fiber, but the less stretchy fibers, such as cotton or linen are easier to work with in crochet. Really stretchy fibers or loosely stitched patterns on larger garments may not work as well in crochet because the weight tends to pull the garment down. That tunic length top may be down to your knees by the end of the day if you have crocheted it in medium weight cotton.

What are some other reasons to choose crochet over knit? Do you prefer to change hook size, choose a lighter weight yarn, or adjust the gauge? Next time, I will write about some of these choices, how to decide, and also give you a list of references that will help you learn the different techniques.

About these ads

6 Comments

  1. August 19, 2012 at 4:42 pm

    When I see a side by side between crochet or knit, to me the knit just seems loose soft and less neater than a crocheted item. It seems like a tension issue. Of course that’s a biased statement since I’ve no clue on how to knit but from what I’ve been exposed to, it seems to be the case.

    • joyharmon said,

      August 19, 2012 at 9:43 pm

      Indira,
      You are right, knit fabric is softer. Because the thread or yarn goes around the needle rather than the hook going through the fabric, as in crochet, it tends to retain the space left by the hook. I am not sure about the neater part. A well made knit piece should be just as nice and even as a crocheted piece. Where the big difference comes in is when you want something that is very soft and drapes well. You can get that effect with crochet, but you will have to work much looser.

      I noticed from your blog that you are doing household accessories, bags, and things that need to be sturdier. Crochet is a good choice for these types of items because you want a sturdier fabric. Also, some people complain that it is very hard to knit with heavier coarser yarn and with fibers like cotton that don’t stretch.

      I see you are a new blogger on wordpress like me. I will be checking in with your posts to see how things are getting along.

      Thanks for commenting.

    • joyharmon said,

      August 19, 2012 at 9:45 pm

      Why don’t you add a comments section to see how people are reacting to your blog. Otherwise all you will get is a count of who has looked at it. I was going to comment on your August 17 post, but I didn’t see a comments spot.

      • August 21, 2012 at 2:08 pm

        Thank so much for checking out my blog. And as you saw I am still pretty unaware on how to handle it as so far I can just handle posting pictures! ;D I’ll definitely look into adding a comments box. I honestly thought that was a default feature. lol Thanks again for your tip!

  2. quirkyp said,

    August 21, 2012 at 9:04 am

    My mum taught me to knit and crochet when I was little. I never really got on with knitting but loved to help my mum crochet hundreds of granny squares for the various blankets and throws she used to make. I’ve recently rediscovered it and find I can easy adapt ideas I have into workable patterns and can see it building as I make it. It’s also easy to undo a few rows if you find you’re going off the lines a bit.

    • joyharmon said,

      August 21, 2012 at 2:20 pm

      That’s great, Quirkyp! That means you have a natural ability to visualize. I can do it sometimes, but really have to sketch out the details on increases and decreases for complicated stitch patterns. How are you with 3-D? I find that I have to work out a small replica of a flat pattern and fold it sometimes to be sure I have the shape right when making a garment that isn’t just a group of rectangles.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

wiredyarn

Antics of two highly caffeinated yarnies and their geekdoms!

Crochet Crusader

All about crochet!

Modern/Vintage

'A Modern Vintage Knitwear Designers Guide to Life'

All about crochet!

Zeebra Designs & Destinations

An Artist's Eyes Never Rest

All about crochet!

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 74 other followers

%d bloggers like this: